Skip to main content

Impressive Non-Sport Card Collection to be Sold May 15

The “Amity Island Collection" will be sold by American Legends, featuring more than 100 high-grade vintage pop-culture sets including Outer Limits, Hit Stars, Three Stooges, Civil War News, Brady Bunch and more.

The “Amity IslandCollection,” one of the greatest untouched classic non-sport collections, is being offered for sale for the first time by American Legends. Meticulously assembled in the 1970s and 1980s by a well-known East Coast collector wishing to remain anonymous, this pedigree collection has sat undisturbed in boxes and binders for more than 20 years.

With more than 30 years of experience in the trading card industry and co-owning a card store since 1992, Mark Rubin has seen many spectacular collections. However, few compare to the recently acquired “Amity Island Collection.”

“I’ve known about this collection since the late 1980s, and I’ve literally inquired about its availablilty every year since,” Rubin, co-owner of Scarsdale’s American Legends, said. “When I was finally contacted last year about the opportunity to acquire it, I jumped at the chance.”

“We’ve purchased hundreds of large vintage collections and have come across some phenomenal material,” Rubin continued. “But we have never bought anything with this scope and quality of Americana. There are well over 100 high-grade sets produced prior to 1976.”

Sets include many of the hobby’s most treasured: the #1 all-time PSA-graded Beatles Plaks Set, Lost In Space, Gilligan’s Island, Outer Limits, Hit Stars, Civil War News, Wacky Packs, Brady Bunch, Leaf Star Trek, Mutoscope Artist Pin-Up Girls and Chiller Theatre, many in pristine condition direct from cello packs or vending boxes.

American Legends is listing all of the items in their eBay store (amerlegends) on Thursday, May 15 in a combination of auctions and fixed price listings.

American Legends is located at 1107 Central Park Avenue in Scarsdale, N.Y. For more information, visit the store’s website at or call 914-725-2225.