Publish date:

Goodwin's Old Judges and postwar blazers

Editor Input Needed

From Old Judges and one Ol’ Perfessor to blazing Goudeys, Bowmans and 1950s and 1960s Topps cards, Bill Goodwin seems to have a knack for turning up both the rare turn-of-the-century stuff and some of the most coveted postwar material in eye-catching shape.

For Goodwin’s next auction, ending Aug. 16, that means a T210 1910 Old Mill Cigarettes Casey Stengel rookie card in SGC 60, a seldom-seen specimen that warrants a $2,500 opening.
Lou Gehrig bats cleanup in the minimum bid department though, with a 1933 Goudey in PSA 9 starting at $18,500, and a 1934 Goudey in the same grade that opens at $19,500. One of the hobby’s legendary rarities, the 1933 Goudey Nap Lajoie, this time in GAI 6.5, carries a $9,500 opening.

Joe DiMaggio weighs in with a 1941 Play Ball in PSA 8 ($4,800) and a 1939 Play Ball in GAI 8 ($1,750); contemporary Ted Williams is also represented from the same colorful set, and in matching condition ($3,000), plus Williams gets showcased in Play Balls from the two previous years (1939, GAI 7.5 – $1,500 and 1940, GAI 9 – $9,500). Ruth gets a swing with a high-grade single-signed ball ($6,000) and an autographed 8-by-10 photo ($2,500) in an iconic image, plus a 1922 Neilson’s Chocolate Type II (PSA 4 – $750) and a 1922 E121 American Caramel in PSA 3 ($400).

There are almost three dozen Old Judges and a similar number of T206s, including the Sherry Magie and Ray Demmitt rarities, several Cy Young (Glove Shows), a 1911 T205 Gold Border Ty Cobb in GAI 7 ($6,995), plus dozens of E90-1s, Standard Caramels and Philadelphia Caramels.

A sterling cabinet card lineup includes Old Judges of Cap Anson ($3,500) and Jack Rowe ($1,000), plus W600 Sporting Life cabinets of Honus Wagner, Mike Donlin, Hughie Jennings and Harry Steinfeldt. Wagner also turns up in an 1910 E-93 Standard Caramel ($750) and in a 1914 Cracker Jack ($950).

Several hundred lots of postwar gems includes nearly a dozen 1948-50 Bowman superstars in GAI 9 holders, a stunning 1953 Bowman Color Stan Musial in PSA 9 ($2,800), eight other 1953 Bowman Color stars in high-grade (plus group lots) and a spectacular assortment of high-grade 1953 Topps, including PSA 8s of Willie Mays ($3,500), Satchel Paige ($1,000), Yogi Berra and Roy Campanella, and PSA 7s of Jackie Robinson and Mickey Mantle ($1,800).

As is the case in any Goodwin & Co. auction, The Mick gets royal treatment with a 1954 Red Heart in GAI 8.5 ($1,800), a 1954 and 1955 Bowmans in GAI 8.5 ($1,500 and $1,085), plus high-grade specimens from Topps issues from 1956, 1963, 1969 (plus the White Letter variation). Ted Williams scores with a 1951 Bowman in PSA 9 ($4,800); Sandy Koufax boasts a PSA 9.5 from 1958 Topps ($2,000), plus there are GAI 9s of Hank Aaron ($2,500), Roberto Clemente ($1,995) and Don Drysdale ($1,000) from the same colorful set.

Goodwin continues his offering of sparkling Red Man Tobacco cards from a find last year, plus there is a boatload of pristine 1952 and 1953 Topps commons, unopened packs, autograph cuts and tough regionals and Topps test issues from the 1960s.

The 72-page, full-color Goodwin & Co. auction catalog will be inserted with next week’s issue of SCD (Aug. 19). For more information, call (314) 849-9798 or go to

Auction of the Week


Charitybuzz's October 2021 Premiere Trading Card Auction

Headlined by the coveted ‘52 Mantle rookie card, and featuring some of the most valuable trading cards in the world. Auction live now through Oct. 28.


Sports Wax Promotions

Halloween Card Show October 30th - Toys, Sports Cards, Non-Sports Cards & Memorabilia